Lecture 02
Date given: Wednesday 7th October 2020
This is the youtube page for Lecture 02. In case you prefer, I have also put a page with the videos on microsoft stream here. Or, if you prefer, you can see the slides with no audio or video here.
Russell’s Principle of Acquaintance
What is Russell’s Principle of Acquaintance? To which question is it supposed to be an answer?
Reading (optional): Russell, B. (1910). Knowledge by Acquaintance and Knowledge by Description. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 11:108–128
Knowledge by Description
There are things you can think about and others about which you cannot think it all. What distinguishes the things you can think about? Could it be that you are acquainted with the things you can think about? No, because you can think about things that you know only by description, like Julius Caesar.
Reading (optional): Russell, B. (1910). Knowledge by Acquaintance and Knowledge by Description. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 11:108–128
Russell’s Argument on Acquaintance
‘I hold that acquaintance is wholly a relation, not demanding any such constituent of the mind as is supposed by advocates of ‘ideas’’ (Russell, 1910 p. 212).
The Argument from Massive Reduplication
The argument from massive reduplication was not intended as an argument for Russell’s principle, although we can attempt to adapt it to that end. But what is the argument from massivie reduplication, and what does the argument aim to show? Does it succeed?
Reading (optional):
- Russell, B. (1910). Knowledge by Acquaintance and Knowledge by Description. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 11:108–128
- pages 20--22 of Strawson, P. F. (1959). Individuals. Meuthen, London.
Conclusion: Acquaintance and Massive Reduplication
Our question is, How do your thoughts connect to the things about which you think? Russell’s Principle of Acquaintance provides one possible answer. It may be possible to justify accepting the Principle of Acquaintance by appeal to the possibility of massive reduplication.
Other lectures
- Lecture 01
- Lecture 03
- Lecture 04
- Lecture 05
- Lecture 06
- Lecture 07
- Lecture 08
- Lecture 09
- Lecture 10
- Lecture 11
- Lecture 12
- Lecture 13
- Lecture 14
- Lecture 15
- Lecture 16
- Lecture 17
- Lecture 18
- Week 01 Questions
- Week 02 Questions
- Week 03 Questions
- Week 04 Questions
- Week 05 Questions
- Week 06 Questions
- Week 07 Questions
- Week 08 Questions
- Week 09 Questions